TF2Maps.net Major Contest #16: Back To Basics [PRELIMINARY VOTING]

[Cargo_Tokens]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | Y
Chin | N
Cliffside | Y
Dipper | N
Escalation (Stage 2) | Y
Hot Garbage | Y
Illinois | -
Shithole | -
Tomb Town | N
Waterlog | Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) | N
Coyote | N
Emil New Thing | Y
Fountain | Y
Red Mesa | N
Route 51 | alein
Tarpit | Y
Tumb 2K19 | -

 

[toopliss]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox |-
Chin |-
Cliffside |-
Dipper |-
Escalation (Stage 2) |Y
Hot Garbage |Piss
Illinois |Y
Shithole |Y
Tomb Town |N
Waterlog |Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) |-
Coyote |Y
Emil New Thing |-
Fountain |Y
Red Mesa |N
Route 51 |-
Tarpit |-
Tumb 2K19 |-

 

[Maid]

Yet to start playtesting these, but since my TF2 has been fixed allowing me to properly get involved in playtests again ill stick a table here for when I do!

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox |
Chin | N
Cliffside |
Dipper | N
Escalation (Stage 2) |
Hot Garbage |
Illinois |
Shithole |
Tomb Town | -
Waterlog | Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) | N
Coyote | N
Emil New Thing | Y
Fountain |
Red Mesa | -
Route 51 | -
Tarpit | Y
Tumb 2K19 | Y

 

[phi]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | Y
Chin | -
Cliffside | N
Dipper | N
Escalation (Stage 2) | Y
Hot Garbage | N
Illinois | Y
Shithole | Y
Tomb Town | N
Waterlog | Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) | Y
Coyote | Y
Emil New Thing | Y
Fountain | Y
Red Mesa | N
Route 51 | -
Tarpit | -
Tumb 2K19 | -

 

[Khuntza]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | Y
Chin | N
Cliffside |
Dipper | -
Escalation (Stage 2) | Y
Hot Garbage | N
Illinois | N
Shithole |
Tomb Town | Y
Waterlog | -
Chemplant (Stage 1) |
Coyote |
Emil New Thing |
Fountain | N
Red Mesa |
Route 51 |
Tarpit |
Tumb 2K19 |

 

[half]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | N
Chin | -
Cliffside |
Dipper | -
Escalation (Stage 2) |
Hot Garbage | -
Illinois |
Shithole | Y
Tomb Town | N
Waterlog | Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) | -
Coyote |
Emil New Thing |
Fountain | Y
Red Mesa | -
Route 51 |
Tarpit | Y
Tumb 2K19 |-

 

[Emil_Rusboi]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | Y
Chin | Y
Cliffside | -
Dipper | -
Escalation (Stage 2) | Y
Hot Garbage | Y
Illinois | N
Shithole | Y
Tomb Town | N
Waterlog | Y
Chemplant (Stage 1) | N
Coyote | N
Emil New Thing | Totally not my map
Fountain | Y
Red Mesa | N
Route 51 | N
Tarpit | Y
Tumb 2K19 | Y

 

[14bit]

MAP | SCORE
Axlebox | Y
Chin | -
Cliffside | Y
Dipper | N
Escalation (Stage 2) | -
Hot Garbage | N
Illinois | N
Shithole | -
Tomb Town | Y
Waterlog | (mine)
Chemplant (Stage 1) | N
Coyote | -
Emil New Thing | Y
Fountain | -
Red Mesa | Y
Route 51 | -
Tarpit | Y
Tumb 2K19 | Y

Tarpit and Red Mesa are my two favorite asymmetric maps right now, and Tomb Town is my favorite symmetrical one other than my own.

If you would like feedback on your map, or want to know why I voted the way I did on yours, just let me know on Discord and I'll write up some feedback for you!

 

[Idolon]

Thread is now closed (late by a bit because I stayed late at work). I'll be tallying the votes and announcing finalists soon.