72hr Mapping Contest #3 - Preliminary Voting

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fruity Snacks

Fruity Snacks

Creator of blackholes & memes. Destroyer of forums
aa
Sep 5, 2010
6,394
5,573
<72hr Mapping Contest #3 - Preliminary Voting!>​

And with the conclusion of the 72 hours of mapping toil, 35 entries emerge! That means that we'll be having a Preliminary vote!

<Voting>​
After you have played the maps, you will then choose between 5 to 15 of your favorite maps, and post them below. They do not need be in any specific order. For your vote to count, there must be at least 5 maps, anything more than 15, the first 15 listed will be chosen. Each vote counts as 1 vote. At the end of the Preliminary Voting round, a cut-off will be determined and narrow the final entries down to a smaller number. The more votes a map receives, the better the chance of moving through. Final Voting will occur after that.

The voting will be open until Weds, July 11th at 12 Noon, EST.
You can adjust your votes as you wish at any point before the above date.

Please leave this thread for voting ONLY. Any discussion should be done in the main contest thread

If you find any server crashing bugs, feel that someone may have cheated by copying from another map or anything that might be against the rules, please PM me on the forums immediately so I can review the situation.

Below are the maps and their screenshots. Map pack at the bottom.
You cannot vote for your own map.

Author|Map name|Screenshot
Sergis|cp_sergis_72| Screenshot
Bermuda Cake|ctf_bermuda_72| Screenshot
Anova|ctf_nova_72_test2| Screenshot
Tech|koth_techtf_72| Screenshot
Ravage|koth_ravage_72_a1| screenshot
MegapiemanPHD|ctf_megapiemanphd_72| Screenshot
Crash|koth_crash_72| Screenshot
Micnax|ctf_micnax_72| Screenshot
Aly|koth_aly_72_3| Screenshot
Zee|koth_zee_72| Screenshot
Tarry H Sruman|tc_sruman_72| Screenshot
bob+MM+|koth_bob_72| Screenshot
Mr. Happy|sd_happy_72| Screenshot
Idolon|koth_idolon_72| Screenshot
Hanz|koth_hanz_72_3| Screenshot
Dark|koth_dark_72| Screenshot
pl|cp_pl_72| Screenshot
AxiomaticFrood|koth_axiomatic_72| Screenshot
Trotim|htf_trotim_72_2| Screenshot
M-L-J|koth_mlj_72| Screenshot
LeSwordfish|cp_leswordfish_72_3| Screenshot
Vaconcovat|koth_vacon_72| Screenshot
drCooper|koth_cooper_72| Screenshot
Ravidge|koth_ravidge_72| Screenshot
TheKieranator|cp_thekieranator_72| Screenshot
English Mobster|koth_engmob_72| Screenshot
GustavoA|koth_gus_72| Screenshot
Terwonick|sd_terwo_72|Screenshot
*Fr0z3n |sd_frozen_72| Screenshot
Fubar|tc_fubar_72| Screenshot
Dr. Element|cp_drelement_72| Screenshot
Mr. Blob|koth_72_blob_a1| Screenshot
Grossfuerst G|fik_grossfuerstsebi_72_a1| Screenshot
Jimmy|sd_jimmy_72| Screenshot

*Fr0z3n got bored, so he made a map in 2 hours to enter. To Reward my speediness, I will not be allowed to win.

Grand Map Pack, courtesy of Tech. Download via Dropbox -still uploading via dropbox-

Again, you have until noon, July 11th to vote. Remember, this isn't about the prettiest map, or the most technical, it's about how well you enjoy them (with all things considered)!
 
Last edited:
Prestige

Prestige

aa
Mar 23, 2010
1,874
1,699
ctf_micnax_72
htf_trotim_72_2
koth_idolon_72
koth_ravage
sd_jimmy


i will try to play as many as i can while trying to be productive. if trotim doesnt get top 5, tf2maps sux!!!
 
Last edited:
Sel

Sel

Banned
Feb 18, 2009
1,239
2,570
htf_trotim_72_2
koth_crash_72
koth_hanz_72_3
koth_idolon_72
cp_drelement_72
ctf_micnax_72
 
Last edited:
phi

phi

aa
Nov 6, 2011
832
1,817
koth_idolon
koth_crash
koth_hanz
cp_pl because we ROLLED and it was fun
koth_axiomatic

htf_trotim is actually the most fun to play on out of all these
koth_ravidge
koth_engmob
sd_happy
koth_aly

koth_ravage
koth_vacon
ctf_micnax

because I can. I'll vote for more when I play them. I have yet to try either of the tc_ maps...
 
Last edited:
Wilson

Wilson

Boomer by Sleep
aa
May 4, 2010
1,388
1,227
koth_hanz
koth_idolon
sd_jimmy
ctf_micnax
koth_tech

More to come in future. (Funnily enough it seems there might not be more to come)
 
Last edited:
Rutiz

Rutiz

L1: Registered
Apr 13, 2009
23
12
ctf_bermuda_72
koth_hanz_72
koth_techtf_72

I'll update when I've played more maps.
 
Sebi

Sebi

L2: Junior Member
Aug 13, 2011
65
13
vacon: (it has trains, it was detailed, it had nice gameplay)
ravidge: (city theme! , 2 CPs!)
english mobster: (detailed, fun to play)
aly: (i really like the idea)
dr element: (a map with no flaws within my perception)
jimmy: (for making a map that was fun for me to play even though i don't like the gamemode)
techtf: (it is really fun to play on + detailed, but please fix the fps issues)
ravage: (pretty jungle theme!, detail, i love the gameplay)
trotim: (for an innovative gamemode)
gus: (i really like the idea, even though the map needs some refinements)

frozen, you linked the wrong screenshot to terwonick's map
 
EArkham

EArkham

Necromancer
aa
Aug 14, 2009
1,625
2,774
Kneejerk voting based solely on screenshots:

koth_ravage_72_a1
koth_techtf_72
koth_aly_72_3
koth_ravidge_72
#5 TBA

And GustavoA & Terwonick screenshots are the same.
 
Idolon

Idolon

they/them
aa
Feb 7, 2008
2,123
6,137
ctf_nova_72_test2
koth_techtf_72
sd_happy_72
koth_vacon_72
koth_ravidge_72

koth_crash_72
cp_sergis_72
bullsjks

I haven't played every map yet, so this is subject to change.
 
YM

YM

LVL100 YM
aa
Dec 5, 2007
7,158
6,079
Firstly: Can we actually play some of these maps without requesting trotim's one over and over? (Why are we hosting casual play events when there are maps to be judged? Poor form)

here's my list: I'll remove names as I play the maps more:

Maps in my shortlist:
koth_crash_72
ctf_micnax_72
tc_sruman_72
koth_bob_72
koth_hanz_72_3
cp_pl_72
koth_axiomatic_72
cp_thekieranator_72
tc_fubar_72
koth_72_blob_a1

Maps I've yet to play:
ctf_nova_72_test2
sd_happy_72


Finally I'd like to say some of the screenshots are appalling, how am I supposed to know what map this is?? And what map is this??

Finally Gustavoa and Terwonic have the same screenshot how am I supposed to know which map is which?
 
Last edited:
Gus

Gus

L1: Registered
Feb 28, 2012
26
17
The screenshot is from my map. Terwonic's map is this: https://dl.dropbox.com/u/8526839/72hr/sd_terwo_720001.jpg

Also, my votes so far goes to
koth_ravidge_72
koth_engmob_72
cp_thekieranator_72
koth_idolon_72
koth_axiomatic_72
htf_trotim_72_2
cp_leswordfish_72_3
koth_vacon_72

And I agree with YM, we need more contest maps' tests.
 
Last edited:
DaBeatzProject

DaBeatzProject

aa
Sep 12, 2008
1,272
1,142
My favourites are:

koth_ravidge_72
koth_hanz_72_3
cp_thekieranator_72
koth_engmob_72
koth_axiomatic_72
 
MetalKev

MetalKev

L2: Junior Member
Mar 5, 2012
70
23
cp_thekieranator_72
koth_engmob_72
koth_hanz_72_3
koth_crash_72
koth_ravidge_72
probably will add more as I play more.
 
Last edited:
Amidio

Amidio

L2: Junior Member
Apr 14, 2012
71
17
koth_idolon_72
koth_bob_72
tc_sruman_72
koth_crash_72
htf_trotim_72
koth_ravidge_72


Will update as I play
 
Last edited:
Rikka

Rikka

L5: Dapper Member
Feb 10, 2009
208
388
koth_hanz_72_3
koth_bob_72
koth_engmob_72
koth_axiomatic_72
cp_thekiernator_72
tc_sruman_72
cp_sergis_72
 
Last edited:
Crash

Crash

func_nerd
aa
Mar 1, 2010
3,348
5,522
koth_hanz_72_3
koth_idolon_72
ctf_micnax_72
koth_ravage_72_a1
koth_techtf_72

And Is it a dick move to vote for my own? Because I want to.

koth_crash_72

Edit: Ok it doesn't count. Hope I make it through!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom