Stockpile B2

[Hanz]

Moar textures and leetle detail!

 

[Acumen]

ive seen it on another map in here recently and now on yours as well. the crate on the tractor wheel just looks out of place, imo. why would anyone put the crate upon there in the first place - it just looks weird and totally random, imo.

same for the pile of random wodden palette props on this screen:
http://forums.tf2maps.net/geek/gars/images/3/0/5/5/ctf_stockpile_a60002.jpg
it looks forced random - which is bad thing, imo. you can keep all the elements but please don't make the crates that fragile looking. it may sound like a minor thing, but i think it looks disturbing in a weird way. also i'd lower the place where the intel is situated. it looks too heavy and massive, i'd say.

the general feel of the place on this screen:
https://dl.dropbox.com/u/754215/ctf_stockpile_a80017.jpg
is lovely, though. i'm liking the vibe i'm getting from it

i think you're on a really good way, just keep an eye on such minor things before you move even further with detailling !

 

[Tinker]

Actually the wooden props pile is the exact same as in ctf_well, and both are used for climbing things (there it's the train, here it's the house). That said, I agree that the tractor wheel, crate and barrels look weird and need to be replaced with something.

And yes, it is starting to look damn good

 

[Jimmy]

looking great Hanz!

 

[MisterNine]

Didn't realize I was stepping on your name until I googled "tf2 stockpile" and saw your map. Sorry for any confusion this causes, I gave a link to yours in my map description.

 

[Hanz]

Didn't realize I was stepping on your name until I googled "tf2 stockpile" and saw your map. Sorry for any confusion this causes, I gave a link to yours in my map description.

Did you change your map name, then?

 

[Hanz]

Do you guys think the gameplay is good enough to go beta?

 

[Acumen]

go and detail and don't ask less important questions like alpha beta naming conventions
it's just a name. doesn't change anything about the quality of your map.
you're just searching for reasons not to start

 

[grazr]

You might wanna look into updating your thread images in the OP.

I'll give it a walk through when i can, but since you get so many impromptu tests it's probably redundant trying to "predict" player habits/tendancies in relation to your maps features.

But i could probably help a little more in regards to detailing.

 

[Waif]

Not enough green in that intel courtyard, feels bland! (Dunno about the rest of the map, just judging from the screen shot)

 

[Hanz]

Ok, the whole map is 99% free of dev textures now and is basic detailled.

Screenshots!

And some rooms with little more detail:

I will probably release an alpha first with the whole map detailled, than fix the issues which could appear, and than go beta.

 

[Randdalf]

The exterior areas look... dire. (Underdetailed). The change of skybox lighting I don't think has helped much at all, there are still huge shadows everywhere. I would've gone for a dimmer skybox, with some exterior lighting to brighten up the dark areas.

The interiors look nice though. I do however question the use of the 100% Grain Quality sign, when there are no grain bags in sight.

 

[owly-oop]

In the interiors i think the dark wood contrasting with the light white concrete wall looks odd, could just be me.

Looks great though :O

 

[lana]

Those signs are too big, especially the "This Job Has Worked 0 Days" sign.

 

[Owlruler]

The shadow on the concrete block in the 4th picture looks odd.

 

[Acumen]

like i said in the chat. the amount of overlays used is quite heavy...
i think you know the "details-how valve does it"-thread but maybe might wanna sneak it up. for the dev state you're in it's just fine, but later on, there sure needs to be more than just pretty signs
overall i'm very impressed with the progress you made so far. this is really shaping up into something very interesting.
still the crate on the tractor wheel is just distracting to my eyes. looks so random :/

 

[Hanz]

Woo! After playing Bad Company 2 too much I finally managed to release a8.

14/03/2010: A8:

- Textured everything and detailled (not fully done yet) the map.
- Optimized a little

Screenshots!

Download!

I forgot to pakrat Novint stuff. -.-

 

[Sel]

Look pretty beast.

You may want to do something more with the intel, it's just sitting there on a block of wood, maybe a wooden pallet, something that doesn't jump out as much as wrong really.

 

[Hanz]

Look pretty beast.

You may want to do something more with the intel, it's just sitting there on a block of wood, maybe a wooden pallet, something that doesn't jump out as much as wrong really.

Yeah, I have been searching for ideas but I can get up with something good. That's also a reason why it's not b1 yet.

If you would have any, feel free to post them.

 

[Hanz]

Right it seems that I didn't pakrat the Novint stuff. -.-

Don't download a8 anymore, I will make a8a now.