You're completely ignoring my point and opting to be sensitive and take my comments as a personal attack. The model doesn't look right, it should be held with with the whole hand, not 2 fingers. Stop acting like i'm hating on it for the sake of hating on it, that's not what i'm doing.
You can disagree with me by all means, i just think your reason and logic given in its defence is flawed. Your excuse that a heavy shouldn't be able to punch a sentry, but can, is a completely different issue to whether a melee weapon looks like a valid weapon in its owners hand.
It's the same with the caber. It clearly wouldn't be a realistic melee weapon but it's a class mechanic related weapon and actually does blow up the demoman most of the time.