Mr. Wimples
L6: Sharp Member
- Jan 27, 2010
- 276
- 226
Bout time for me to come back and do something. Hope I'm not late to the party.
TF2Maps.net Contest #8 - KoTH, Sponsored by STAR_
- Thread starter Fruity Snacks
- Start date
Hey guys, we are still taking judges applications for this:
Please PM me on the FORUMS with a little blurb saying why you are interested/would be a good judge!
Please PM me on the FORUMS with a little blurb saying why you are interested/would be a good judge!
Can judges be announced before they post their reviews this time? Is that something that's never done.
We've never explicitly came out and said "Hey, here are the judges" because by the time that the announcement would pop up, all the judges were like "hey, I'm a judge" and everyone knew.
I don't see the need for revealing the judges ahead of time.
As a judge for the last big contest, it was kind of nice that none of the mappers knew that I was. I just quitely played the maps with everyone else and based my review on that. I can already picture judges getting pocket medics and more attention thrown at them, just to increase how much fun they have on a given map. I'd say it's best to leave it somewhat in the dark just to avoid any situation where something like that might happen.
Judges should have the same experience playing the map as everyone else.
As a judge for the last big contest, it was kind of nice that none of the mappers knew that I was. I just quitely played the maps with everyone else and based my review on that. I can already picture judges getting pocket medics and more attention thrown at them, just to increase how much fun they have on a given map. I'd say it's best to leave it somewhat in the dark just to avoid any situation where something like that might happen.
Judges should have the same experience playing the map as everyone else.
Friendly reminder about this rule
ZooL
L1: Registered
- Dec 30, 2011
- 32
- 13
i've already added it in this
http://forums.tf2maps.net/forumdisplay.php?f=56
what should i do after ?
http://forums.tf2maps.net/forumdisplay.php?f=56
what should i do after ?
If your map was added to that forum before August 12th, then you'll have to officially submit your map in the upload thread that will be going up on the 23rd. It closes on the 30th.
Check the rules for more information.
So, we still need Aesthetics/Technical Judges.
?
Yes, that is okay, as long as they do not touch the map in any form.
You will need to pack any custom content, build all cubemaps, etc.
HI!
I'm not dead, I'm just... killing dragons... and centaurs... and zombies... and dragons...... dragons.
But, I didn't forget that today was the last time to get your map fixed. So, here is the final map pack (Still uploading!)
22 entries. That is a lot! Goodluck to all of you! I'm extremely happy for the turnout, and hope that everyone is proud of their work.
Remember, there is no public voting. Judges have been asked to remain silent through-out the judging process, so don't pester them if you know who they are. STAR will release the winners via YouTube and then judges remarks will be released shortly after.
You are welcome to play and update the maps as you please. If you find anything that might break the rules, please notify me immediately on the forums or on steam (if I'm on)
Again, excellent work to everyone.
-Fr0z3n
I'm not dead, I'm just... killing dragons... and centaurs... and zombies... and dragons...... dragons.
But, I didn't forget that today was the last time to get your map fixed. So, here is the final map pack (Still uploading!)
22 entries. That is a lot! Goodluck to all of you! I'm extremely happy for the turnout, and hope that everyone is proud of their work.
Remember, there is no public voting. Judges have been asked to remain silent through-out the judging process, so don't pester them if you know who they are. STAR will release the winners via YouTube and then judges remarks will be released shortly after.
You are welcome to play and update the maps as you please. If you find anything that might break the rules, please notify me immediately on the forums or on steam (if I'm on)
Again, excellent work to everyone.
-Fr0z3n
There is no preliminary voting, i understand. The judges just go straight to it.
Correct.
STAR_'s judges will be doing the final decision on what maps make it through the prelims. No more than 15 will go through, but at least 3 will make it through. This is how it was elected to be done based on STAR's requests. I'll notify the Aesthetics/Technical judges when STAR has made the final cut (So they can save some time). I am not sure if I can release the final list publically yet, I will check with STAR when the cut is made. Don't pester the judges.
And now, back to dragons.
STAR_'s judges will be doing the final decision on what maps make it through the prelims. No more than 15 will go through, but at least 3 will make it through. This is how it was elected to be done based on STAR's requests. I'll notify the Aesthetics/Technical judges when STAR has made the final cut (So they can save some time). I am not sure if I can release the final list publically yet, I will check with STAR when the cut is made. Don't pester the judges.
And now, back to dragons.