CP Jess72 A4

[Lain]

Maybe we have yet to see a Badlands/Viaduct type map to set the trends yet. Hopefully that comes sooner rather than later.

 

[worMatty]

You are probs best taking this to a thread about 3CP, not discussing it in Mudpie's thread about her own 3CP map.

 

[Muddy]

Hey, any discussion is better than none!

 

[tyler]

My judge feedback stuff, presented here in an easier to read format:

cp_jess72

I think you've had it with this map so I'll make it quick.

http://i.imgur.com/HKJ1PzR.jpg
Should probably cut or change this. It's one too many routes past the point.

I still get lost in the bases sometimes, but I think that's a reflection of the detailing (no rooms are unique) more than the layout.

http://i.imgur.com/bzICsFo.jpg
Only rocket jumpers can ever see this stuff, but everyone renders it. Naughty.

Really this feels like another map that is almost good, and just suffered from being done in 72 hours. Maybe leaving out detailing would have given you time to improve the layout a bit. I don't know. I think you should make a new version with a lot of changes and try it out again. This was one of the better 3CP maps in the contest, despite its flaws.

+ good mid
+ i like last
- too many routes around the point
- feels overscaled outside

5/10​

​