72-Hour Mapping Contest #2 Preliminary Vote

[REEJ]

grazr
Languid
Loc_n_lol
h3r1n6
Sergis
TomHoen
Ravidge
LeSwordfish
YM
DaBeatzProject

in no particular order

 

[Tekku]

Ravidge
Hanz
Sergis
YM
Leminnes
Frozen
Beatz
Mangy
Super
Ezekel

There we go, 10 favourite maps.

 

[h3r1n6]

grazr
Leminnes
Sergis
DaBeatzProject
YM
RaVaGe

Edit:
Do I have to vote ten? These are my favorites, after that it would become a bit random of a selection.

 

[tyler]

frozen
ezekel
leminnes
hanz
swordfish
prestige
grazr
zhan
ayesdef
supersandvich

maps that i like the most or have the most potential imo that i have played, and i'm close to having played them all

 

[MangyCarface]

finalized:
super
ym
zhan
dabeatz
ravidge
frozen
ezekel
locnlol
hanz
trotim

 

[Grim Tuesday]

In No order, so far:

Fubar
Lemines
Ezekel
Zhan

 

[YM]

Damn this is taking forever. I'm playing as much TF2 as I can handle and I've only played 14 entries, that's not even half of them!!

I've written up a few very brief notes on each, mainly to jog my memory when it comes to picking 10 to go through, I'll probably post that when I'm done.

Its taking soo loooong! D;

 

[ANova]

Let's pick our top 5

 

[Sel]

Top 10 in order

Super
Mangy
Frozen
Hanz
Prestige
Trotim
Ym
Sergis
Ezekel
DBP

I'd also like to shout out to Ritz's map which despite not playing very well, was still very interesting, and might work well as a point in a 5cp or something bigger.

PS: Congrats to everyone who entered too, just finishing something on time is great in itself.

 

[Bockagon]

In no order:

Sergis
YM
Frozen
Ravidge
Psy
Prestige
Fubar
Leminnes
Ezekel
Super

I was really impressed with all of the maps considering the time limit. Congrats to everyone who made it and thanks to everyone who took the hours to play them all!

 

[ssupermario92]

My Top 5
cp_ezekel_72_1
cp_sniprpenguin_72
cp_trotim_72
pl_ayesdyef_72_a2
ctf_mangy_72

 

[Fruity Snacks]

(you should have 10, thats what muffin would like you to pick, the top 10)

 

[sniprpenguin]

WIP:

pl_ravidge
cp_ezekel
72_nova_test1
cp_hanz_72
cp_tomhoen_72
plr_supersandvich_72_3

4 more because I can't in good conscious pick any more from those I've played, and testing seems to be over with, so going with the pack:

pl_ym_72
plr_leswordfish_72_2
plr_zhan_72_02
cp_languid_72

 

[Tom Hoen]

WIP

MangyCarface
Sergis
Fr0Z3n
YM
Ravidge

Still lots of maps which I haven't played

 

[Ezekel]

... Still need to play : ...

you missed a couple of maps on both your lists (you've got only 35 maps listed instead of 38).

 

[Zhan]

Here's the current tally as of about 9 AM PDT July 3rd:
https://spreadsheets.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?hl=en_US&hl=en_US&key=tLo2rRml1bhInik-hGkDaqQ#gid=0

EDIT2: Updated as of July 6th 9:30 AM PDT

 

[DaBeatzProject]

koth_psy
cp_trotim
cp_hanz
pl_ym
cp_ravage
koth_omnomnick
ctf_mangycarface
plr_leswordfish


more to come later...


edit:

plr_zhan

edit 2:

cp_frozen

 

[Omnomnick]

No particular order

arena_kierantator
koth_dabp
pl_ym
plr_leswordfish_72_2
cp_frozen
ctf_mangy
pl_ravidge
plr_super
koth_sergis
plr_zhan

 

[Sergis]

Mangy
Zhan
Fubar
Reej
Supersandwich
Frozen
Leminnes
Psy
Ezekel
YM

 

[Boylee]

I have to say congratulations to everyone who entered, I didn't expect to see so many entries that are actually fun to play and have the potential to be really good maps, so if you took part give yourself a pat on the back, you did well.

Here's my shortlist in no particular order:

cp_ezekel_72_1
pl_ym_72
cp_frozen_72
koth_grazr_72
pl_leminnes_72
cp_hanz_72
plr_zhan_72_02
cp_ravage_72
koth_psy_72
koth_reej_72

EDIT: I should add that I'm judging these as maps that I'd most like to see finished, by no means do I think they're perfect and some even had some glaring errors, but I felt they had the most potential to be real stand-out maps. When I get around to it I'll leave some more feedback about them, just started a new job though so I have v. little time though right now.