I'd like to thank everyone for the really helpful feedback. As I said, this is my first map so there was a lot of unknowns for me when implementing my design. I'm disappointed I couldn't be in the servers for all of the plays of the map (my friends kidnapped me for too-much-drinking and cult movies), but I still think the feedback I have will contribute greatly to getting this map playable.
The trees are pretty rough. I jumped into them from a path above them and got stuck.
I'm chewing over this. When I reduce the map size there's a pretty good chance a number of trees will come out. I wanted the trees to be a sort of chaotic cover from enemies high up, but there's no overwhelming reason why players need to go over the top of them. So I'm thinking maybe of player-clipping that area off.
The location of cap point A is pretty counter-intuitive from the spawn right next to it....possibly because point A is below the spawn IIRC.
I'm thinking more signs to lead to A in general is a must, but I was also considering adding a hatch that drops straight onto the point from the spawn room...
I really dislike the spawn to the left of C....it seems too high and out of the way to me...but I'm not sure what exactly what you're going for in regards to spawn locations.
I'll probably be bringing that spawn in closer to the point. But the idea of the design of that point is that the defenders can spawn and go up into the overhead shaft and drop down on key areas around the point. I've yet to watch the SourceTV demos, so I haven't seen all the play, but as far as I know I don't think anyone really discovered that route, which is bad since it's supposed to be pretty pivotal to the defenders' maneuverability at C. So something I'm considering there is to actually move the spawn room upstairs and point one of the exits into the shaft, and the other to downstairs.
this got some bad reception at gameday, don't take it to heart because 99% of the issue was size. *no pun*
The map is just WAY to big and lacks proper signing.
Scale down the map, get a lot more signs in there, and fix your clipping.
Layout wise i didn't see to wrong. With the current size of the map however its hard to give any sort of feedback on class balance. Keep it up!
Yeah for the first few minutes I was a little embarrassed, but really I didn't expect a glowing response. I'm just glad people managed to highlight as many useful points as they could given how the map played.
Yea, i'm not sure i can speak about class balance effectively when the teams had some fairly good players all on one team during this match.
The major complaint was height, although i did enjoy gameplay flow around point B. Travel wasn't always as bad as most people seemed to make out and i say that when playing a soldier, but it could get annoying if you keep getting taken out by sneaky enemies behind the lines. It was quite easy to get lost on your own. My main complaint would probably just be the long corridors that connect everything up.
Yeah when I thought about it later my guess was that one of the main culprits is all the mundayne connection areas. I'll be focusing a fair bit of attention in culling those and pushing the gameplay into the main combat areas.
Point A seemed impossible to find, i seemed to walk past sign after sign and never reach it. Classes of choice were scout for speed, and soldier and demoman for their explosive jumping techniques. Sniper was also a favourite but the scouts seemed to deter most of them.
The general size meant that players did go wandering off on their own which could be a problem in pub play, people got lost in being able to rocket/grenade jump around the place which distracted them from the goals.
Cap times seemed reasonable boardering on the long side. Fix your spawn signs.. a couple times i got taken out when retreating only to find a broken door, or atleast, the spawn said it was blue when it was infact red (The one overlooking B).
Actually I didn't consider the sign colours such an important detail when I was getting the map ready for gameday, but now that I've thought about it I needed to be very clear with that, so I'll be working considerably on clarifying spawn points for the next version.
You need to reduce the general size of the map to justify engineers and smooth out game flow and generally balance all the classes. Reduce some heights. Vertical combat is a significant part of TF2 gameplay and it's good that you noticed this, but at times it was a bit much.
Yeah I've been having a number of ideas for evening out the heights on areas to give people a bit more of a break from them, and in general I think the heights will need to be lowered a little just to work on a smaller-area map. In fact I think the current heights are one of the key contributing factors to the grossly oversized area of the map.
Don't completely ignore the gameday/SourceTV footage. You did get some constructive comments as well.
Oh of course. I actually recorded my own personal demo as well, and went over it a few times taking down notes on issues people had. I'm downloading the SourceTV stuff now and am eagerly waiting to check it out.
