- Nov 7, 2015
- 33
- 8
(IK ABOUT THE FEEDBACK SECTION BUT SOME PEOPLE DON'T HAVE TIME FOR GAME DAY THIS IS IF A PERSON IS RUNNING AROUND THE MAP ALONE OR WHAT SO EVER)
Yea I was looking through my map's comments and I realized that a lot of the criticism on there was from version Alpha 1 and I wondering if people just go straight to discussions to see if the map is good or not obviously that makes sense even if you do have a picture from now you still don't know how it is but a lot of the criticism is from A1 and yes I understand there are loads of maps on tf2maps and some of the lesser known people get little to none feedback but the little feedback I have gotten has helped me greatly improve but there was one from A1 that had 3 agrees two days ago and now has 4 agrees and the map now in A4 looks way better then it did when it was in A1 was about releasing the map early --NOTE-- I understand how rigorous webpage making is but I think these two would help maps that don't get much feed back another thing I am mainly talking about visitors to the site who just dl the maps they might read only one feedback and be like that it is a bad map
Comments , Advice, Criticism, and Shia la buff grade "just do it" *
So to start off when posting something in the forums before you click ok you have to click on either comments, advice, criticism, and just do it And author should be allowed to upgrade and downgrade so if a comment is more like advice then they can do it with out the posters permission but if a criticism is more of a comment the author of the map has to state the reason why the downgrade is happening the person who wrote it will have a chance to review it before making a decision and click yes or no BE FAIR the numbers i put down are just guesses on who will agree just to mention the upgrade is probably not needed but it would make sense but I don't think any one would have time to do so im only suggesting it because the same thing isn't said in the correct section
Comments: They are comments so it isn't really adding to the map its more like how you felt the map was and just rambles the thing is that comments can be deleted by author so if its just gibberish it can be taken down but so they are the least serious of the four or in other words a personal opinion so if someone its just talking because of something someone said that would be a comment
Advice: More serious the advice is something that about 50% of people would agree with and is usually bent towards the author and not really the map the Advice section can be resolved so it will be flagged as resolved
Criticism: well I want to know what you think this is can be resolved
just do it: lets say you screwed up something but didn't notice it but someone did and should be fixed fast because it might hinder game play Things like game play changes, map decor changes, lighting changes, etc Should not be in here unless it is hindering the game also this should be used less and less over time
(can be resolved)
Well what do you think
*Shia la buff grade "just do it" is copyright lololololololol of Lunacy productions and the Shia la buff estate
and what ever Charity made that stupid video **
*its not actually copyrighted don't worry it's a secret to everyone
Yea I was looking through my map's comments and I realized that a lot of the criticism on there was from version Alpha 1 and I wondering if people just go straight to discussions to see if the map is good or not obviously that makes sense even if you do have a picture from now you still don't know how it is but a lot of the criticism is from A1 and yes I understand there are loads of maps on tf2maps and some of the lesser known people get little to none feedback but the little feedback I have gotten has helped me greatly improve but there was one from A1 that had 3 agrees two days ago and now has 4 agrees and the map now in A4 looks way better then it did when it was in A1 was about releasing the map early --NOTE-- I understand how rigorous webpage making is but I think these two would help maps that don't get much feed back another thing I am mainly talking about visitors to the site who just dl the maps they might read only one feedback and be like that it is a bad map
Comments , Advice, Criticism, and Shia la buff grade "just do it" *
So to start off when posting something in the forums before you click ok you have to click on either comments, advice, criticism, and just do it And author should be allowed to upgrade and downgrade so if a comment is more like advice then they can do it with out the posters permission but if a criticism is more of a comment the author of the map has to state the reason why the downgrade is happening the person who wrote it will have a chance to review it before making a decision and click yes or no BE FAIR the numbers i put down are just guesses on who will agree just to mention the upgrade is probably not needed but it would make sense but I don't think any one would have time to do so im only suggesting it because the same thing isn't said in the correct section
Comments: They are comments so it isn't really adding to the map its more like how you felt the map was and just rambles the thing is that comments can be deleted by author so if its just gibberish it can be taken down but so they are the least serious of the four or in other words a personal opinion so if someone its just talking because of something someone said that would be a comment
Advice: More serious the advice is something that about 50% of people would agree with and is usually bent towards the author and not really the map the Advice section can be resolved so it will be flagged as resolved
Criticism: well I want to know what you think this is can be resolved
just do it: lets say you screwed up something but didn't notice it but someone did and should be fixed fast because it might hinder game play Things like game play changes, map decor changes, lighting changes, etc Should not be in here unless it is hindering the game also this should be used less and less over time
(can be resolved)
Well what do you think
*Shia la buff grade "just do it" is copyright lololololololol of Lunacy productions and the Shia la buff estate
and what ever Charity made that stupid video **
*its not actually copyrighted don't worry it's a secret to everyone