In & Out - Detailing Contest 2021 [VOTING]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Spacek531

L4: Comfortable Member
Jan 28, 2012
165
94
Checked in too late to join the contest, but not too late to judge. I curved the score where 100 is the best entry and 0 is full dev textures.

MAP | SCORE | COMMENTS
Averyc1876 |69| Wood distress very nice. Weather, lighting, and masses outside are nice. Interior feels a bit bare
Dotmd |70| Very good lived-in garage look, and exterior is fine, but they feel like two scenes that share a single bsp
DrSquishy |78| Flooded area reminds me of INFRA - neat. The buildings feel storied and lived in
Evynbktothbse |20| The trims on the buildings as seen from outside is nice, but interiors are completely bare
Fiddleford |99|Original TF2 map detailing but a cut above
Mattie |100| Audacious, effective, and hilarious
Olikat |30|Despite having many of the appropriate props, it doesn't feel much like a diner
Pdan4 |60| Beautiful once I successfully sentry jumped up above, unfortunately bare on the interior despite very nice brushwork
Punnamesardum |50|Lighting was very harsh, bumpy displacements, felt a bit empty, but neat layout
Stack_Man |90| Feels like an original TF2 map detailing, comparable to something like goldrush
Swagmeister |40|Missing light fixtures and feels somewhat bare
TurnsIntoCroc |87|Very nice, but what did poor trainy do to you?
YoshiMario |85|Outside feels barren but inside is quite nice
 

Pdan4

Still trying to add
aa
Nov 25, 2013
127
327

MAP | SCORE | HONORARY TITLES
Averyc1876 | 45 |
Dotmd | 75 |
DrSquishy | 80 |
Evynbktothbse |15 |
Fiddleford | 90 |
Mattie | 92 | Best Attention to Detail
Olikat | 25 |
Pdan4 | Own | Own
Punnamesardum | 20 |
Stack_Man | 85|
Swagmeister |27 |
TurnsIntoCroc | 80 |
YoshiMario | 65 |
 
Status
Not open for further replies.