im thinking of remaking a...

Sean of the Dead

L3: Member
Dec 30, 2007
123
4
im also thinking of remaking The Pit from Halo 3 for TF2. it would probably be a CP map, but CTF would be possible :D
 

Intraman

L4: Comfortable Member
Nov 4, 2007
191
0
I think this is more suited for the mapping discussion and not the WIP forum. We could use a "what maps should be remade for TF2" thread anyway.
I, personally, would love to make a version of The Edge for quake 2 as a gravel pit like map.
 

Sean of the Dead

L3: Member
Dec 30, 2007
123
4
I think this is more suited for the mapping discussion and not the WIP forum. We could use a "what maps should be remade for TF2" thread anyway.
I, personally, would love to make a version of The Edge for quake 2 as a gravel pit like map.

meh, w/e xD

yeah, someone should make a thread where ppl request maps to be remade :D
 

A Boojum Snark

Toraipoddodezain Mazahabado
aa
Nov 2, 2007
4,775
7,669
I think remakes should be avoided in general :/ Remakes of old fortress maps can work, but game-to-game conversions usually don't work too great.
 

Logo

L3: Member
Oct 25, 2007
115
26
I strongly dislike halo 3 =/.
The game felt rather uninspired to me (Playing MP that is). Halo 1/2 were decent and enjoyable to play with friends so while not a big fan of the series I did get some enjoyment out of the earlier games.

As for remakes it's probably best to use the map you want as inspiration rather than a direct remake. What makes a map a good layout is a lot different between games.
 

DJive

Cake or Death?
aa
Dec 20, 2007
1,465
741
I strongly dislike halo 3 =/.
The game felt rather uninspired to me (Playing MP that is). Halo 1/2 were decent and enjoyable to play with friends so while not a big fan of the series I did get some enjoyment out of the earlier games.

As for remakes it's probably best to use the map you want as inspiration rather than a direct remake. What makes a map a good layout is a lot different between games.

QFT^^

I've always thought HALO was a descent console game, but nothing in comparison to PC gaming.