Map reviews?

[Captain Planet]

What happened to them?
I like to see more map reviews, especially on the ones that get played less.
Because its always nice for a mapper to hear what is good and wrong about there first / second map before they start mapping on the other map. Because otherwise they would just get the same problems.

 

[grazr]

Provided that a mapper isn't arragont he will usually learn what he has done wrong through the development process and improve upon it in later projects.

A review will normally only confirm a map's playability. Everyone else can see for themselves whether it's pretty, stylised, trimmed at the egdes (bloom control, sprites on server models, shadow control, keen attention to detail).

The W.I.P. section allows for anything more demanding, as each update gets critised by the community in a more in depth way than a review ever could.