Timbermill

PL Timbermill rc3c

Freyja

aa
Jul 31, 2009
2,994
5,813
It has been run on countless severs back in the hay day for tf2 and may people use to ask me if It was going to be officially added to the game, and that it
was one of their favorite maps.

All things aside, don't use this to judge the quality of your work. I've seen people say to make this official on a1 maps, on joke maps, even on trade maps. People have literally no idea what they want.
 
Last edited:

infectedfury

L3: Member
Aug 30, 2008
124
39
I'm sorry. but I'm seriously pissed off with this site.
edit
you guys were just the unlucky ones for me to vent to. it wasn't at anyone in particular.

I wouldn't mind any of negative feed back I I got it last year!!!! I was completely left in the dark until I asked about what was happening with showcases and found out that there had been testing.

It is know that this site has a bad rep and it had been stated may times before that something was going to happen about it. but nothing has!!!
 
Last edited:

Wilson

Boomer by Sleep
aa
May 4, 2010
1,385
1,223
I don't think anyone can deny the site and community are sometimes stubborn and hard to deal with, but claiming there is some sort of secret inner circle that you need to be part of to succeed is stupid. If there was some sort of inner circle that decided your success, i don't think people like Frozen would have come out of nowhere with no experience and eventually evolve into someone who worked on big projects and is site staff.

Besides, i think not getting any feedback is partly on you. I have seen this map in a public test once and that was long time ago. Outside of that, i don't think i personally have ever seen you in the chatroom, tests, submit your map to gamedays or in general interact with the community outside threads about your own maps. How can you expect to get feedback from people you don't ever actually interact with in any way? Feedback doesn't just automaticly always find it's way to you, you have to go get it. There is only so much you can do with map threads and feedback system.

That's my 2 cents.
 
Last edited:

killohurtz

Distinction in Applied Carving
aa
Feb 22, 2014
1,016
1,277
I would also like to point out that your map's feedback page only has comments from 3 days ago, last month, and October 2014, which was shortly after you posted your map - indicating that you have gotten maybe three playtests from this site. Like Wilson said, it's up to you to submit your map for testing, because we rarely, if at all, pull random maps from the workshop to test, especially if the mapper never interacts with us. It's no surprise your map has slipped under the radar.

That being said, you have over 200 comments on your feedback page despite he scarcity of the playtests, which is far from the "very small feedback" you claim to have gotten from here. You may also think that this community's feedback is harsh, but try not to confuse our thoroughness with negativity. We have relatively higher standards because we care to see your map become the best it can possibly be.